Gun Tests Magazine has reviewed dozens of holsters over the last few years, involving all the major types and price points. In this listicle, we’ve selected the best of each major type as part of the Top 10 choices, and we’ve listed all the others as Honorable Mentions at the bottom.
The concealed-carry holster should be chosen as carefully as the carry gun or defense load. There isn’t a shortage of manufacturers and custom makers, but gun owners continue to choose holsters that are cheaply made and that do not perform well. Cant, angle, and drop have a bearing on how well the handgun rides on the belt. The holster must carry the pistol as comfortably as possible while maintaining a balance of speed and retention. That is a tall order.
The holster must offer a speedy draw while also maintaining a firm hold on the firearm during movement. A floppy holster is worthless as far as both speed and retention is concerned. Passive retention is simply the natural retention of a holster, designed into the holster by offering a hold on the long bearing surfaces of the handgun. Active retention is additional protection, including a safety strap, thumb break, or other device. The more retention, the more movement that’s required to free the handgun from the holster. A balance should be struck. Some holsters use a thumb break, while some feature a button or plunger to release the handgun safely.
And for the car-carry types listed below, we must address some legal issues. Many states prohibit a handgun in the passenger compartment. Period. If you have a concealed-carry permit, you may drive with the pistol holstered, but a concealed-carry permit in your state may not allow you to drive with a pistol on the seat or under the seat or dash. Conversely, other states specify the handgun must be in plain view on the seat, and still others specify the handgun must be in the dash or console. So right off the bat, many of these devices can’t be used because they are illegal in your state. Know your local and state laws.
Happily, we encountered very few failed products that were dangerous to use, but we did find a few favorites that were listed as Best Buys or Our Picks, the latter category not being constrained by price. As always, you can read the full review about a holster in the monthly issues cited in each listing. — Todd Woodard
10 Galco Great Alaskan Chest Holster, $289 (August-September 2025)
Gun Tests Grade: A-
The Great Alaskan is the most expensive chest holster tested. That said, the Galco holster is also a type that sets a high bar for all other holsters. The Great Alaskan is a combination of materials — leather, nylon straps, plastic keepers, metal Chicago screws. Attention to detail sets the Great Alaskan apart. The holster component is what Galco calls high-grade steer hide. The holster is nicely finished and tanned. Fit to the Smith & Wesson 686 Plus test gun is snug, offering a good balance of retention and speed even without the safety strap. We recommend using the safety strap if climbing or hiking. To carry spare ammunition, there are several options. The Galco Cobra speed loader pouch at $69 is well made and secure, with a strap that folds over the speed loader. The Pick6 is nice, not tested, but seems excessively expensive for our needs at $96. The Galco 2X2X2 is probably the best choice. It features sections with two cartridges in each compartment, separated by leather. This item was found on sale at $34.50 and seems to be the better choice for outdoors use. This is a good holster and is an excellent example of holster craftmanship. We had to rate it down a half grade on draw speed, but that is par for the course in holsters that use this type of safety strap. Find out more at GalcoGunLeather.com.
9 Crossbreed The Reckoning Holster, $58 (April 2025)
Gun Tests Grade: A
Suitable for the SIG P365, the Reckoning hybrid holster (CrossbreedHolsters.com) has a hard Kydex holster mated to a supple leather backing. The Kydex holster is actually a half shell with the leather backing retaining the handgun as well. The half-shell design allows the shooter to get a good firing grip. The hard shell provides retention while the leather backing offers good comfort. The Reckoning’s belt clips are adjustable and take a good bite of the belt for security. There is some adjustment for drop, either a high ride or low ride, by moving the belt clips. Retention may be adjusted by tightening the shell against the backing. The Reckoning is designed for tuckable carry. This isn’t an option we recommend, but in that role, The Reckoning is as good as any. We tested as an IWB. We drew from the holster several times with a good, sharp draw. There was no difficulty in re-holstering. The backing is comfortable and seems to spread weight out well. The Reckoning is affordable and does exactly what it was designed to do.
8 Safariland 126GLS Assent Holster, $91 (November 2022)
Gun Tests Grade: A
Our Pick. Safariland and Bianchi are now branches of the same company. This higher-retention holster is the most expensive tested. By the same token, you get your money’s worth. The leather work and stitching are excellent. Our example is the size 750. We used a Sphinx compact 9mm during the test program. The pistol worked much the same as the Safariland; however, due to the OTW construction, the draw was sharper. One of the raters felt that there is very little penalty in actuating the GLS switch — practice is the key, but the movement is natural. He felt the GLS lock moves the holster into usefulness when hiking or doing outdoors work. We like this holster very much. Unless you have a pressing need for ITW carry, this is a good choice for concealed carry. We rated the construction far above the paddle holsters for concealed carry. With price as no object for our testers, this is the top retention holster. Find it at BianchiLeather.com.
7 Gungoddess.com Steering Wheel Column Holster Mount, $40 (August 2023)
GUN TEST GRADE: A
We found this car-holster mount to be very secure. The mount features two hooks that attach just to one side of the steering column. There is plenty of leeway for comfort and access or left- or right-hand set up. We were surprised at the ease of the draw. While a mount or magnet may be hidden, in this case the steering column served as a point of reference in leading toward the handgun. It is much easier than drawing from a holster on the belt. Reach down and bring the handgun up toward the center of the chest. Being certain the mount is adjusted as tightly as possible is the trick. We recommend a fabric holster such as the Uncle Mike’s model illustrated. Falco and a few others offer a similar holster. The holster must incorporate a safety strap into the design. While the handgun may stay put in a tightly fitted holster, and some leather holsters work okay, you really need the combination of Velcro and a tight belt-loop connect. Line the mount up, properly tighten it, and you have a solid mount. And drawing the pistol without covering the body isn’t difficult.
6 Jeffrey Custom Ranger R Leather/Alligator Trim, $235 (September 2019)
Gun Tests Grade: A+
Left-handed shooters need not despair for a custom holster. This is arguably one of the finest holsters we have tested; an excellent choice for concealed carry. It was priced at $155 for the Ranger R holster with leather lining, available on JeffreyCustomLeather.com. Add $80 for the alligator trim. Most custom makers advertise a wait of three to six weeks, but Jeffrey Custom Leather is usually ahead of the game for this delivery. Such a wait is realistic considering the work and effort that goes into such a holster. We ordered our Ranger R for the Colt Detective Special. Because one of the raters has been wanting such a holster for some time, he popped for the alligator trim. While alligator is very rugged and will protect the gun and the shooter for many years, is it a vanity more than a needed upgrade? Only the user may make that decision. Fit is excellent. It took some effort to shove the revolver into the holster. After wearing the handgun holstered a few days, the break-in resulted in excellent speed. The hand goes to the holster and a quick tug brings the revolver into action. Retention is excellent, and so is the balance between speed and retention. The holster was also worn on the back near the right kidney to test its use for special chores with a right-hand draw. It worked well. The Ranger R is arguably one of the finest holsters we have tested, making it an excellent all-round choice for concealed carry.
5 DeSantis Uni-Tuk, $101 (April 2025)
Gun Tests Grade: A
The Uni-Tuk is a highly developed inside-the-waistband holster for the SIG P365. It is also useful as a tuckable type. The Uni-Tuk features an adjustable belt loop with a strong hook to ensure stability. The belt hook is behind the half-shell polymer holster. This makes for less bulk in concealed carry compared to a holster with the belt loop on the front of the holster. This design also brings the holstered handgun into the body more closely. The Uni-Tuk features hybrid construction. The holster shell is Kydex, while the backing is a foam-filled design. This backing is well suited to constant carry in humid climates. Since a Kydex shell cannot collapse, there is no need for a holstering welt. The holster body itself features a tab to one side of the belt loop that seems to prevent rollout when carried in the appendix position. We found the Uni-Tuk equally well suited to inside-the-waistband, tucked under a shirt, or appendix carry. This is easily the most versatile holster tested.
4 Sam Andrews Monarch Shoulder Holster, $455 (April 2020)
Gun Tests Grade: A+
One of the raters called the Sam Andrews rig “pure class.” Well thought out with good features. The base price for the Monarch was $275 at AndrewsLeather.com. We added a Knife pouch, $55, and a triple magazine pouch, $125, for the total price as listed above. The Andrews holster is called the Monarch because of the Monarch butterfly–like harness. The Monarch is a classic holster in some ways, but in other ways it is unique. The Monarch is exceptionally well put together. The holster body is lined. While this is critical in protecting the gun’s finish, a holster with a lined interior will wear longer as well. With modern handgun finishes or even older blued-steel handguns, handgun wear isn’t a big issue. Just the same, this is a nice touch. Some of the raters felt that the lined holster made for greater speed.
3 Falco Appendix A909 Holster, $140 (April 2025)
Gun Tests Grade: A
There are options on the Falco website (FalcoHolsters.com) that may affect the final price. Our holster as delivered for the SIG P365 is the priciest holster of the test. We don’t see how it could have been less expensive considering the work that goes into the A909. This holster is all-round comfortable design with the Kydex shell covered in calf skin overlay. The backing is supple leather, very well finished. While the Kydex component is prominent, there is plenty of give to wrap the holster under the belt line. It features a removable anti-roll-out foot. The belt loop rides over the holster and a clip rides near the magazine carrier. The ability to carry the gun and magazine together by simply fitting the holster to the belt is a good feature. It is best to use a sweat guard in this type of rig. This protuberance behind the holster protects the gun from perspiration and the body from oil, solvent, and discomfort. In this case, both the holster and the magazine carrier feature sweat guards. A minor concern is that you may need to bump the sweat guard to the rear as you holster. It is simple enough to slightly angle the muzzle into the holster. We find this to be a credible combination. While pricey, there is a lifetime warranty.
2 Don Hume Leathergoods D.A.H. Belt Holster, $78 (July 2021)
Gun Tests Grade: A
On the DonHume.com site, we ordered the D.A.H. for a Smith & Wesson Model 36 Chief’s Special 2-inch-barrel revolver. The holster is an interesting design, with three belt loops for use as an SOB holster or as a high-ride strong-side holster. When worn in the small-of-the-back configuration just behind the hip, the holster offered a reasonably fast draw. The snubnose 38 Special doesn’t take up a lot of belt space. The holster angle is decent, and the D.A.H. makes a viable holster. However, when worn in the strong-side attitude, the D.A.H. was not as secure. The grip frame is handle heavy in the Smith & Wesson, and the holster tilts too much. We would not use the holster as a strong-side choice. With the belt loops in the SOB position, the holster works well.
1 Tulster Contour, $80 (November 2022)
Gun Tests Grade: A
The higher-retention holster is certainly low profile. The Contour is an outside-the-waistband (OTW) holster. It rides high and offers an option for those who cannot find comfort with the inside-the-waistband (ITW) style. We tested two examples, one for the Glock 19 size and the other for a Smith & Wesson Military & Police 2.0 Compact. The standard version is optics friendly. The pistol features asymmetrical wings that ride close to the body. The Tulster features a Retention Adjustment Slot. Simply adjust the slide vertically and then tighten the slot for added retention. The holster may also be adjusted for ride height. The Kydex material is .08 inch thick. This holster is a good choice for those who want a bit more retention. The draw may be fast enough, but the movement requires a solid tug — still faster than detaching a security device. After setting the holster up for maximum retention, we used an unloaded handgun and jumped up and down, and one of the raters did a back flip, all without losing the gun. If you are not comfortable with an IWB type holster, consider the Contour. Available at Tulster.com.
—————————————————————————————
HONORABLE MENTIONS
Galco Hornet, $99 (April 2025)
Gun Tests Grade: A
The Hornet (GalcoGunLeather.com) is a crossdraw OWB especially designed for small-frame automatics like the SIG P365 and revolvers. The Hornet is cut from high-quality leather. The tanning is well done. The crossdraw requires a specific geometry. It doesn’t work to simply take a standard holster and wear it on the wrong side. The Hornet is well designed of good material and cut at the correct angles. The belt loop keeps the holster cinched tight to the belt. The tunnel loop is a welcome feature that results in a good, tight fit to the belt and cinches the pistol in rigidly. This tightness results in a good fit and keeps the gun butt angled properly and tight against the body. A crossdraw that allows the gun butt to tilt forward isn’t well suited to concealed carry. Drawing and re-holstering the pistol went smoothly. The Hornet offers good concealment under a light jacket or unbuttoned sport shirt. An OWB is never as discreet as the IWB. The Hornet is best suited to those who are often seated at work or who drive most of the day. This is a good choice for certain situations.
Crossbreed Magna-Arm Gun Magnet, $20 (August 2023)
GUN TEST GRADE: A
One of the raters found this while on the prowl for car retention devices. The company recommends it for static use under a desk or attached to furniture. But a clerk in a local shop recommended this magnet for car carry, so we tried this device in a car, in a state where its use is legal. A rubber covering protects the pistol’s finish when attached, but the handgun is exposed. We dropped the combined gun/magnet from a 6-foot height, and the magnet did not dislodge. The magnet is easily mounted in a location of your choosing with a power drill and flat-head Phillips screws in wood or plastic, or you can use heavy-duty double-sided adhesive tape. Where there’s steel available, the magnet will also stick strongly to a metal surface with no other fasteners.
Using a triple-checked unloaded handgun, we attached the Magna-Arm. We did not test momentum in an actual vehicle, but instead attached the Magna-Arm and a snubnose steel-frame 38 (triple-checked to be unloaded) to a heavy safe door and slammed the safe door several times. The device worked held the gun in place. This seems to be a good solution to several issues. A strong tug is needed to dislodge the pistol from the magnet, but the magnet may be mounted practically anywhere off the subject. If mounted in a car, would the gun fly loose in an accident? Depends on the speed.
We caution the reader to ensure you’re in compliance with state laws about display of firearms in plain view. Also, the gun should be mounted in the car where it won’t muzzle sweep the passenger or the user’s legs or body.
Gungoddess.com Sticky Holster Travel Mount, $35 (August 2023)
Sticky Holster, $30
GUN TEST GRADE: A
For what it was designed to do, this works well. This car-carry holster combination prevents the handgun from flopping about in the glove compartment or a center console. A rater mentioned he thought pressure would hold it between the seats. Sometimes yes and sometimes no. It is better in that role than using a handgun without a holster. The combination of the holster holder and Sticky Holster is recommended because the travel mount alone isn’t as well suited to holding a handgun. If you use the holder, leave it in the console and remove the sticky holster as you deploy the handgun. A relatively rapid draw is available once you open the console lid or glovebox, but only if you use the holster in the carrier as designed. The combination does what it is designed to do and rates an A in that niche. We would not use it anywhere else except inside a glove box or console.
Safariland GLS Pro-Fit, $48-68 (November 2022)
Gun Tests Grade: A
The Grip Locking System (GLS) is an ITW design. Safariland has an enviable reputation in law enforcement and has been a recognized leader in security holsters for many years. The GLS polymer higher-retention holster is designed to fit a range of handguns and may be manually adjusted. As an example, the Glock 19 and S&W M&P Compact may be worn in the same holster with appropriate adjustment. The Safariland grip locking technology holds the handgun with high retention, but the handgun can be released immediately by the proper action. Using a triple-checked unloaded firearm, we found the pistol could not be shaken from the holster. Upside down, or attempting to lever the gun butt against a chair, nothing worked to dislodge the handgun. Yet the pistol could be instantly released by pressure on the grip-lock lever. Cant is also adjustable. When ordering this holster, there are four sizes, from subcompact up and at least four types of mounting hardware for different-size belts and paddle or belt attachment. See it at Safariland.com.
Galco Summer Comfort Thumb Break Holster, $82 (November 2022)
Gun Tests Grade: A
The Galco Summer Comfort is among the best values in an ITW holster. Quality is practically the same compared to a custom-shop holster. The molding to the handgun is good, and the higher-retention holster features a reinforced holstering welt. This means that the holster does not collapse after the handgun is drawn. The handgun may be holstered without adjusting the belt or trousers. One of the raters wears an open-top IWB for most of the summer. During the winter, when he bikes and hikes, he likes more retention. The Summer Comfort has a thumb-break option. It is very important that the thumb break is reinforced. If not, the leather extension will bind on the belt and body at some angles, making a draw difficult. The Galco design is reinforced properly with a spring-steel clip and heavy molding. We find the thumb break IWB from Galco to be a good option. As for draw speed, several of the raters tested the holster and felt it needed a modest break in. Compared to an open-top holster, there is perhaps 0.2 second difference in draw speed, depending on how much practice the user has. Check it out at GalcoGunLeather.com.
Galco VHS 4.0, $279 (July 2022)
Gun Tests Grade: A
We tested a single shoulder holster, the Galco Vertical Holster System, which has been reviewed
previously. The holster is well designed, affordable, and offers a nice load-bearing device for getting the weight of a handgun and spare magazines off the belt. Some vertical shoulder holsters feature a design that butts the slide into the holster itself. With the vertical design of the Galco holster, the design work was undertaken to make the holster optics ready. The slide cut-out allows easy clearance. The holster body offers good retention, and a security strap improves the holster’s hold on the
handgun as well. Available from GalcoGunLeather.com.
Wright Leather Works Predator Pancake Holster, $105 (July 2022)
Gun Tests Grade: A
Making a holster adapt to an optic demands some thought. Wright has accomplished this neatly.
DeSantis Slim-Tuk Optics-Ready Holster, $40 (July 2022)
Gun Tests Grade: A
Best Buy. The DeSantis Slim-Tuk is not only an optics-ready holster, it is a light-bearing holster.
Galco QuickTuk Cloud, $69 (July 2022)
Gun Tests Grade: A
This is a holster designed with a supple leather backing and a strong Kydex shell. It is among the most popular styles and a strong seller for every major holster company offering a variation. The QuickTuk Cloud features excellent fit and finish. The holster is properly molded. Either carefully tuck the red dot in, or adjust the belt loop. We found the QuickTuk Cloud to be a well-made and versatile holster. Comfort is high on the list. This holster is available from GalcoGunLeather.com.
DeSantis Speed Scabbard, $83 (July 2022)
Gun Tests Grade: A
This is a semi-pancake-type holster. The Speed Scabbard features three belt slots for cant or angle adjustment. The holster is molded for specific handguns and features slight variations in geometry for each handgun. This is a holster designed with care and which serves well for concealed carry. There is also a tension screw to adjust tightness on the handgun and to tighten the holster up when it becomes worn. Available from DeSantisHolster.com.
DeSantis Veiled Partner, $42 (July 2022)
Gun Tests Grade: B-
This is another holster that exhibits the advantages of Kydex. The good points include that the holster hugs the body. In that way, it is similar to a leather pancake holster. The holster offers plenty of adjustment for drop, rake, and cant. The holster rides high, and we experienced a few problems with stability. This one is available from DeSantisHolster.com.
Wright Leather Works Predator Pancake Holster, $105 (July 2022)
Gun Tests Grade: A
Making a holster adapt to an optic demands some thought. Wright Leather Works has accomplished this neatly with judicious modifications. The Predator is a pancake-style strongside holster. The fit and molding are far superior to a standard pancake. Many pancakes are not molded as well as this one. The holster rides close to the body, and the result is good concealment. Available from WrightLeatherWorks.com.
Wright Leather Works Cruiser IWB Clip Holster, $105 (July 2022)
Gun Tests Grade: A
The Cruiser is a single belt clip inside-the-waistband holster. The holster is well designed, secure, and offers a sharp draw. The balance of speed and retention is good. One of the raters owns three he uses with handguns ranging from a 32 ACP to a Commander 45. So, the question was, how do you convert a relatively compact holster to take an optics-ready handgun? Wright doesn’t let the red dot/reflex optic touch the holster body. The offset is slight, but when the handgun is holstered, there is plenty of retention while the red dot offset from the holster is perhaps 1⁄8 inch. This is a neat trick, and the system works well. Available from WrightLeatherWorks.com.
Galco Corvus Optics-Ready Holster, $89 (July 2022)
Gun Tests Grade: A
The Corvus holster is a versatile rig with belt loops that allow both on-the-belt and inside-the-waistband carry.
Wright Leather Works Bronco, $105 (July 2021)
Gun Tests Grade: A
Modifies the original SOB design. The cant is raised, with the gun butt up and accessible at 20 degrees.
Bullard Leather Mfg. Striker, $140 (July 2021)
Gun Tests Grade: A
The company took the harsh tilt of the SOB and made it a 25-degree tilt and invented the Bodyguard.
Galco FasTrax PAC Fanny Pack, $99 (July 2020)
Gun Tests Grade: A
We sometimes forgot we were wearing the PAC because it didn’t sag, and it moved with the wearer.
Tulster AIWB Kydex, $60 (May 2020)
Gun Tests Grade: A
The Tulster Appendix holster and magazine carrier are good choices for concealed carry.
Werkz M6 AIWB, $50 (May 2020)
Gun Tests Grade: A
The Werkz IWB offers good features, including a special foot that prevents rollout in appendix carry.
Galco King Tuk Classic, $37 (May 2020)
Gun Tests Grade: A
Features a hard Kydex component attached to steerhide, which makes for comfortable carry.
DM Bullard Bodyguard Standard, $295 (May 2020)
Gun Tests Grade: A
This hippo-hide Bodyguard was the most expensive holster tested. Surprisingly comfortable.
Nelson Holsters Stealth, $120 (May 2020)
Gun Tests Grade: A
Among the most comfortable and well-crafted holsters we have tested. Neoprene backing is a trademark.
Galco Jackass Shoulder Holster, $152 (April 2020)
Gun Tests Grade: A
This is a horizontal design. Most of the raters put the Galco Jackass near the top in ratings.
Viper Holsters Shoulder Rig, $159 (April 2020)
Gun Tests Grade: A
Compact and lightweight. The Viper features a sturdy Kydex holster. Tabs and harness are well made.
Lobo Gunleather Deputy Shoulder Holster, $215 (April 2020)
Gun Tests Grade: A
Chromed components and keepers are sturdy and make for both good adjustment and a bit of flex.
DM Bullard Shoulder Holster, $225 (April 2020)
Gun Tests Grade: A
A revolver holster. The offside straps are not very wide, but they are strong, a good point in its favor.
Galco Gun Leather Phoenix Crossdraw Belt Holster, $159 (February 2020)
Gun Tests Grade: A
For a heavy revolver or 1911 handgun, this is a robust holster that offers a superior design for load bearing.
Bullard Leather Holsters Crossdraw 1911 Series, $90 (February 2020)
Gun Tests Grade: A
Well molded and provided a good, snug fit. After months of wear, the Bullard holster is still tight and useful.
Blackhawk! Sportster Holster, $18 (September 2019)
Gun Tests Grade: A
Inexpensive, but we cannot call it cheap. For those owning several firearms, this is good to have.
Jason Winnie Little Problem Solver, $30 (September 2019)
Gun Tests Grade: A
At home on either side of the body, either as a belt slide or as an inside-the-waistband holster.
Barber Leather Works Chameleon, $30 (September 2019)
Gun Tests Grade: A
Ambidextrous, offered in two sizes. Intended to “tide the shooter” over until he receives a custom holster.
Swap Rig Holsters Cargo Pack2, $40 (September 2019)
Gun Tests Grade: A
Intended to hold a pocket pistol or backup in cargo shorts or pants pockets. Ambidextrous, adjustable.
1791 Gun Leather Open Top Revolver Holster, $53 (September 2019)
Gun Tests Grade: A
The work is custom grade. Stitching is blocked to prevent unraveling. Impressive for the price.
DeSantis GunHide Flex-Tuk ITWB Holster, $66 (February 2019)
Gun Tests Grade: A
The design complements the short-barrel revolver very well. Speed, comfort, and draw angle are excellent.
Galco N3 Inside-The-Waistband Holster, $87 (February 2019)
Gun Tests Grade: A
The N3 features a reinforced holster mouth and a raised sweat guard, requisites of a quality IWB holster.
Jeffrey Custom Leather EZ Carry, $99 (February 2019)
Gun Tests Grade: A
Offers a good, sharp draw. Offers secure carry with a very strong spring steel clip, yet is easy-on-and-off.
Galco Triton IWB, $52 (January 2019)
Gun Tests Grade: A
The Triton is designed as an IWB but worked well in the appendix role. Retention was excellent.
Lobo Leather Offset Belt Clip IWB, $68 (February 2019)
Gun Tests Grade: A
Best Buy. The design works well for lighter handguns, especially those that are worn in the appendix position.
Wright Leather Works Banshee, $108 (February 2019)
Gun Tests Grade: A
Our Pick. Retention is good, yet offers a fast draw, with minimal break-in. Wide range of adjustment.
CYA IWB, $38 (January 2019)
Gun Tests Grade: A
Best Buy. The holster is secure, providing the wearer uses a quality gun belt.
GearCraft IWB Plus, $70 (January 2019)
Gun Tests Grade: A
If you do not wish the holster to extend to the belt buckle, do not choose this holster.
JM Custom Kydex AIWB with wing claw, $90 (January 2019)
Gun Tests Grade: A
Shows mature design, good execution. Has an anti-roll-out device that keeps the holster tight against the body.
Keepers Concealment Errand, $90 (January 2019)
Gun Tests Grade: A
Billed as a holster for faster on and off use, yet it is said to be capable for all-day use.
Bullard Leather Belt Slide Holster, $100 (April 2025)
Gun Tests Grade: A-
Belt-slide holsters are a staple for compact pistols like the SIG P365. While not as concealable as an inside-the-waistband holster when you have a short-slide pistol such as the SIG P365, you have a good candidate for concealed carry among those shooters who cannot tolerate an IWB design. The Bullard Leather Belt Slide (BullardLeather.com) features double stitching, an important reinforcement in a leather holster. The design is blocked and molded properly and has a sweat guard. Edging, the part of the holster where the two halves meet and are glued together, is flawless. Draw speed is sharp. You may have to budge the holster mouth a bit with the muzzle on re-holstering, and we rated the holster down a half grade on that respect. If you are transitioning from 1911s and leather to a modern polymer-frame gun, this holster will have much appeal.
DeSantis Criss-Cross Crossdraw Holster, $80 (April 2025)
Gun Tests Grade: A-
The Criss-Cross is a leather cross-draw design suitable for the SIG P365. The leather is nicely tanned. Linen stitching makes for a nice contrast. We like the draw angle; it allows sitting at a table or desk with your hand practically on the gun butt. When driving, the holster is easily accessible. Fit is good. On the reverse side, you can see double-stitched saddle-blocked linen thread. The Criss-Cross features a retention adjustment screw. This works well for adjusting tension and also for tightening it up as the holster leather becomes worn in daily use. A good feature is a heavily reinforced holstering welt. No problems in drawing and re-holstering with the Criss-Cross. This is a well-thought-out holster. DeSantisHolster.com.
Galco Stow-N-Go, $40 (April 2025)
Gun Tests Grade: A-
The Stow-N-Go is a leather inside-the-waistband holster intended to offer an IWB holster for the SIG P365. The holster welt or holster mouth is reinforced and did not collapse when the pistol is drawn. Re-holstering generally went fine; occasionally, we had to tuck the muzzle into the holster and slightly budge the holstering welt open. A plastic belt clip is well designed, anchoring the holster to the belt during movement. We think the Stow-N-Go is an affordable alternative to pricier holsters such as the Summer Comfort. We rated it down a half grade on the holstering welt, but gave it a Best Buy.
Galco Walkabout, $60 (April 2025)
Gun Tests Grade: A-
The Walkabout is similar to the Stow-N-Go, the primary difference being that the Walkabout features a magazine holder. The advantages of the Stow-N-Go are retained. The holster features a reinforced holstering welt. The fit is good, and in our example accommodated both the SIG P365 and the slightly larger Hellcat. If worn as an appendix-style holster, the magazine carrier is an asset. If worn as a conventional IWB holster, the magazine carrier is on the wrong side for a rapid acquisition. However, the point may be made that some shooters would not bother to carry a spare magazine without a holster/carrier combination. It is slower to change the gun to the weak hand, draw the magazine, and then swap hands again, but better than digging in the pocket for a magazine or not having a spare magazine. If worn as an appendix holster, the Walkabout is more affordable than purchasing a holster and a carrier. A tester made the point that if worn as a tuckable with the optional supplied tuckable clip, once the shirt is pulled out, the magazine carrier is exposed as well, a good point. The draw angle is nearly infinitely adjustable by means of an adjustable belt clip. We almost made this holster the Best Buy, but the lower price of the Stow-N-Go won out.
Mission First Tactical (MFT) Inside-The-Waistband Holster, $55 (April 2025)
Gun Tests Grade: A-
This MFT holster features a 1.5-inch belt clip. The clip takes a good hold on the belt. Surprisingly, the MFT holster features adjustable cant for the SIG P365. One of the mounting holes is large enough to allow some adjustment. There is also a retention screw. The holster is manufactured of 0.08-inch-thick Boltaron Kydex. The holster is equally suited to right-hand or left-hand carry. While advertised as suitable for appendix carry, it depends on the user’s build and whether or not rollout is an issue. The holster also may be used OWB if you order an MFT paddle. We wore the MFT design for two days with the SIG P365. It rides well and offers a good draw. Re-holster isn’t a problem. One rater noted that the sight track is nicely developed. The sights did not snag in any other holster, but the MFT features a prominent sight track. One of the raters felt the belt clip had too much flex, but going back and testing the other holsters, all have a bit of give. The large belt clip of the MFT holster has more leverage; it is wider than most. We sometimes tested a holster and went back to others to confirm our opinion. The MFT holster is a good choice, well worth the money. We would like thicker material at 0.10 inch, and we rated the holster down a half grade on this mark. MissionFirstTactical.com.
Wasatch Chest Holster, $80 (August-September 2025)
Gun Tests Grade: A-
This holster was ordered for a Glock 17. It features a Kydex component attached to a nylon harness that was more of an L than an X shape. Adjustment is good. Comfort is good, with the holster not grinding into the chest, but it isn’t as well padded as the more expensive holsters. To test for retention, we snapped the holster to the end of its harness like a whip. Unlike some open-top holsters, the Wasatch never lost its hold on the pistol. We went to considerable effort and found retention to be excellent. When worn and properly adjusted, the draw was sharp. However, due to the retention features, you cannot draw the pistol slowly. Give the handgun a sharp tug, and the handgun comes out of the leather quickly. You may wish to adjust retention for less force if it fits your needs. At the tightest setting, a good hard tug cleared the holster, but it was difficult to access the pistol if the holster was hung on a bedstead or attached to a pack — a consideration, but we really liked the balance of speed and retention. Wearing the pistol, the set up is comfortable. We would have liked a bit more padding, as in the case of the Crossbreed or the JM4, but then these holsters cost a lot more. In the end, there is little fault to be found with the Wasatch holster. We rated it down a half grade for its lack of padding. See more about it at WasatchHolsters.com.
JM4 Tactical Holsters Relic Series Chest Rig, $190 (August-September 2025)
Gun Tests Grade: A-
We ordered this holster for a 5-inch-barrel Government Model 1911 without rail. This holster is available for a range of handguns and left- and right-hand options. This holster is unique in some ways. The holster isn’t pricey compared to some of the holsters tested, but it isn’t inexpensive. The construction is complex. A hard Bolatron polymer shell is mated to stitched leather, not only backing the holster to allow comfortable carry, but also inside of the holster itself. JM4 claims a silent draw due to this lining. Per our testing, they achieved that goal. The draw is smooth and rapid and also silent, save for the snap unfastening. Even so, if you don’t need speed to unsnap the safety strap, as in hunting, and work the snap slowly, you have a very quiet holster. Fit is good on the 1911, and the draw is smooth and quiet. In common with the other holsters with a safety strap, we rated the JM4 Relic down a half grade on draw speed. The holster passed every retention test. It should be noted that the holster is compact enough for concealed carry under a heavy jacket. Some may elect to ignore or remove the safety strap in this carry mode. If so, retention isn’t that good, in common with any other open-top holster. The holster is designed to be used with a safety strap. The nylon straps and attachments are easily adjustable. This holster has a range of possible draw angles and cants due to the many holes punched in the holster and the possibility of changing attachment points. A practically horizontal draw was possible to set up. It was possible to set up a type of conventional under-the-arm carry, but it wasn’t completely satisfactory and was beyond the design envelopment. Check out the JM4Tactical.com website for more on this holster.
Diamond D Outdoors The Denali Chest Holster, $98 (August-September 2025)
Gun Tests Grade: A-
A separate entity from Diamond D Custom Leather, the Outdoors company was founded to offer a quality holster at an economical price. The holster is manufactured of 1050 nylon, which is, as far as we know, the toughest of several grades of nylon. The Denali addresses the only real issues with leather, and those are cost and weight. The Denali isn’t a one-size-fits-all model, but it is available for a range of sizes in both autoloader and revolver sizes, offering an accommodating fit for several handguns. As an example, a Ruger GP100, Colt Python, or Smith & Wesson 686 fit easily in one size holster, but you can order for a Glock 17, and the pistol version comes in fitting several polymer-frame handguns from long slide to compact. The holster we ordered was for a 6-inch-barrel S&W 629 and also used with a 5-inch 629 Classic and S&W 686 Plus 3-inch barrel, all with good results. This holster got a lot of attention based on price, versatility, and comfort. There is nothing cheap about it, but it is affordable. Learn more at DiamondDOutdoors.com.
Diamond D Custom Leather Guides Choice Chest Holster, $225 (August-September 2025)
Magazine Pouch, $55
Gun Tests Grade: A-
We ordered the Guide’s Choice for a 1911 handgun with a spare magazine pouch, adding $55 to the price. The Guide’s Choice was developed and first deployed in Alaska. This holster is the gold standard, by all accounts, but only one rater was familiar with the type, having used an example for the Ruger Blackhawk 4 5/8-inch revolver for many years. Shoulder holsters are usually not as secure as a belt holster because retention must be a bit loose to allow a sharp draw. The Guide’s Choice bucked that trend with a holster offering excellent retention attached to a shoulder rig, but by placing the shoulder strap on only one shoulder, movement isn’t restricted and carry is more comfortable. A mid-chest stabilizing strap makes this design viable. The holster component is well designed, with a good tight fit. It may require break in, which is a good thing in custom leather. As you know, 1911 handguns are not consistent in size, so a tight fit you do yourself is a good thing. The Guide’s Choice features good molding, a strong spine, and excellent stitching. The harness is well designed, with plenty of adjustment. The harness is well suited to either a high-chest or low-chest carry with a greater tilt than some, a kind of a crossdraw type. The Guides Choice is a well-made holster. We recommend adding a magazine carrier or the $40 ammo carrier for revolvers. Get more details at DiamondDCustomLeather.com.
DeSantis Yukon Hunting Rig, $104 (August-September 2025)
Gun Tests Grade: A-
The Yukon Hunting Rig is a ballistic nylon holster. We found the DeSantis chest rig at a fair price at OpticsPlanet.com, and at as much as $166. An average price is $121. Availability with different firearms is good at the maker, but the price and availability varies on line. We gave the DeSantis a high rating on fit and adjustment. The back face of the Yukon Hunter features six attachment points for the carrying straps. These are drop loops. The straps use spring-hook attachments. The holster could easily be attached to a backpack or ATV if not carried as a chest holster. If there is a shortcoming, it is in draw speed. The clasp used for security requires moving to unsnap the safety strap, then moving to draw the handgun. The Yukon Hunter is a good economy holster and may be all you will ever need. It isn’t inexpensive, but then it doesn’t cost as much as many of the others. We rated it down a half grade on speed of the draw. But it is a hunter’s holster, so speed may not be important. Find out more at DesantisHolster.com.
Crossbreed Custom Shop Chest Rig, $160 (August-September 2025)
Gun Tests Grade: A-
We ordered this holster for the Glock 17 9mm. The Crossbreed is a three-point harness design with a Kydex shell over a padded backing. Notably, the third of three retention straps features a metal buckle that is very sturdy. The holster gets high ratings as an easy-on-and-off type. It is possible to mount a spare magazine carrier on the carrying straps of the Crossbreed holster. The Crossbreed Accomplice magazine carrier at $35 is a good set up. However, dual magazine carriers with a Velcro strap for security are commonly available for less than $20. They sacrifice speed for security and are not a bad setup for the field. A clip-on carrier would be okay for most applications. We like the Crossbreed and give it a solid rating for most uses, with the only demerit coming when the gun slipped out during extreme testing. See more at CrossbreedHolsters.com.
Hogue ARS Carbon Fiber Paddle Holster, $30 to $59 (November 2022)
Gun Tests Grade: A-
Be certain to shop around because we found a wide range of prices for this higher-retention holster. The carbon-fiber construction is attractive. If you like paddle holsters, this one works well. The paddle is broad enough for security, but is fairly compact. There is good adjustment. The primary concern is the ARS locking device, which works by applying thumb pressure. Get a firm grip and press inward with the thumb to release. The lock is automatic, not applying a thumb strap or anything such as that. You don’t have to think about the retention device, and you should not have to think about releasing the device if you have several hundred draws under your belt. We found the Hogue holster to be well made and useful. The draw was reasonably fast. While we prefer the Safariland system, this holster may be the preferred type for some shooters. We rated it primarily on the usefulness of the lock mechanism. We don’t like the paddle offset for concealed carry. Find it on Amazon.com.
Galco Switchback Strongside/Crossdraw Belt Holster, $49 (July 2020)
Gun Tests Grade: A-
The Switchback goes well beyond what we’d ask for in a budget utility holster.
Galco Gun Leather Switchback, $46 (February 2020)
Gun Tests Grade: A-
Best Buy. While we prefer some of the more expensive driving holsters, the Switchback is useful.
Alpine Products Universal Pistol Slicker, $65 (August-September 2025)
Gun Tests Grade: B
The holster is useful, we feel, primarily for outdoorsmen. In the end, as a backup for a hunter, the Pistol Slicker has merit. We rated it down on the draw angle a half grade, and also a half grade on the open-bottom holster. We liked the ability to shield the handgun from the weather and easy adjustment. Learn more at AlpineProducts.com.
OTHER HOLSTERS
No Name Chest Holster, $22 (August-September 2025)
Gun Tests Grade: D
This holster is the odd one out due to its price and construction. During the research stage, the raters found similar holsters on Temu, EBay, and Amazon. One rater said, “It is our job to test these holsters, and someone will purchase this one.” The holster features three straps. The construction is a combination of thin leather with a suede backing on the straps. Edging where the two halves of the holster are glued together is good. Stitching isn’t high quality, and we saw where the thread is thinner than on the other holsters. When wearing the holster, the testers felt that the chest strap gave too much during normal motion. It did pass the drop test. This holster is suitable for only the most casual use.
Blackhawk SERPA Level 2 Sportster Holster, $29 (November 2022)
Gun Tests Grade: B
This is a lighter-weight higher-retention holster than the full-size Blackhawk holsters. The Sportster with its lighter paddle is designed for concealed carry. All raters found it better made than the less-expensive ITAC. The paddle, however, was still a bit skimpy for hard use, we felt. The holster and trigger-guard locking mechanism worked well. We ordered this one for a snubnose 38 Special revolver. As such, the draw, when properly executed, is very fast. The paddle offset helped with speed.
We think there are better holsters for concealed carry, however, because the offset of the holster demanded a heavy covering garment to conceal the gun butt. The holster does what it is designed to do, but we do not like the trigger-finger release as much as we like the Hogue and Safariland types. See it at Blackhawk.com.
ITAC Defense Roto Retention Paddle Holster, $20-$33 (November 2022)
Gun Tests Grade: B-
This higher-retention holster is of thin material, the first demerit. Fit seems good enough. There is too much flex in the paddle, and we felt that the holster was not secure. There are tabs on the paddle portion, however, that keep the paddle clipped on the waistband. The give we found when shaking the gun butt seems in the paddle/holster attachment to the holster itself. We do not like the retention device. When the handgun is pressed into the holster, the handgun locks on the trigger guard. The plunger to release the handgun is located just below the trigger. To draw, you must slightly press the gun inward toward the muzzle/bottom of the holster and press the release inward. This releases the handgun. We found this system slower and less natural than the Safariland. We also did not like the rapid movement of the trigger finger toward the trigger after release, something that would require considerable training to overcome. We simply did not like the system. Available at Amazon.com.
