I am truly glad the imaginary baby rock is #1 on the list. Having looked hi and lo for one since 2016 I myself would have named the Starfleet phazer a better weapon of choice since neither one exists.

F Y I:

The Sig P938 is NOT a .380 as you indicated, but rather a 9mm; however,
the Sig P238 IS, in fact, a .380.

Easily confused, they are otherwise virtually identical, except, of course, their calibers !!!

Looks as if everyone has their favorite 380. My daily carry in warm weather is the G42 and when I'm feeling nostalgic I get out my trusty Colt Government 380 which I had night sight put on special and it is extremely accurate and reliable. All my tactical courses were with Glock so the familiarity with them is a given. I'm still an old timer with 1911 love affair, but I have modernized my armory a bit. :)

Even though it wasn't mentioned, it was also the first pistol I ever purchased, I like the Browning BDA380, it has the same operating controls as the Beretta 92FS, carries 13+1 rounds, and is in every one I've used besides mine, 100 percent reliable. It's only drawback was it's really nice bluing. You have to stay on top of her or she will start to rust. Accuracy is also very good!!!

Quit screwing around with the sissy .380. The Rohrbaugh, in NINE MM, is smaller and lighter than EVERY .380 on the list.

I really like my Beretta 85 380. I love the unique dot on v-dot sights. It is very well made and shoots much like my 92fs.

"Best" based upon what? Modest recoil? I might agree that in my hands, the LCP Custom would not recoil that much, but in less experienced hands, or in the hands of a less stout person, recoil would be significant, especially compared to the CZ or Baby Rock.

While I like many of the comparisons and conclusions made in your publication, I am befuddled when I read so many articles comparing apples to oranges. OK, they are both round, but that's about it... You can't honestly compare a pocket pistol like the LCP to the CZ 83! They are two completely different weapons built for different purposes. Each has advantages over the other, depending on its intended use.

You're never going to please everyone, because there's always someone out there who has a personal favorite and will be offended that you didn't mention it. That's just the way of it, and I understand. You have to limit the selection if you're ever going to get the article published in a timely manner, while keeping it informative, yet succinct.

I am more and more dismayed by some of the comparisons I've seen in the past two years. It is as though someone is getting desperate looking for something to write for. If you're going to test something, then do it. List the pros and cons, what you liked, and disliked, and let us make the decision whether or not to purchase. If you're going to rate one gun against another, make sure they are in the same category and were made in the same era.

You surprised me. The Baby Rock is a joke. The dealers don't even have them.
The trigger on the new Springfield Armory is the best by far. Super smooth, crisp and no creep.

Shame on you.

I'm also wondering why the Colt Mustang wasn't on this list when 2 other 1911 builds are. It's a great pocket pistol with minimal recoil.

I'm dismayed that no Colt is mentioned. I've got a Mustang Pocket Lite that performs with all ammo,after market Tritium sights added to it make ideal for its purpose. I've also acquired a Colt Pony some what smaller & lighter my wife likes the easy slide retraction and has no trouble with the trigger. I may mount a laser on the trigger guard of it for her.

You have mentioned the CZ-83 and the fact that it is no longer produced, but yet you fail to mention the Sig p230/P232 (which is no longer produced)? The Beretta models 84/85 are still in production and these were omitted? In my opinion, I beleive these pistols are better than some of the ones you've reported on and should not have been left out.

Maybe this article should have been titled... "Five best .380's priced in the $300-"400 range"?

I have the 2nd rated Ruger LCP-C Custom and one of the few objections I have to it is it's lack of a safety. It is very compact and a nicely made pistol, but somewhat difficult to disassemble and reassemble. I believe this model Custom with the red trigger is no longer made, but you may be able to find it at gun shows or on the internet. However, I would not buy a gun without a safety...........my mistake. Also, the newest model of the LCP is an ugly pistol compared with this older model. I would go with the CZ model 83 ( if you can find one ) or the number 1 rated Rock Island Baby Model ( although it is quite a bit larger than the Ruger LCP-C Custom ).

I also have two Bersa Thunder 380s ( the normal and the concealed carry ) which are very similar to the Walther PPK. I find them well constructed and attractive pistols. However, in shooting them I was surprised by the recoil ( kick ) of these Bersa pistols which was greater than some larger caliber pistols in my possession . Perhaps this is because of the weight and size of these pistols. Regardless, I would put these on this list of desirable 380 pistols. They also have a safety ! I am 84 years old and a gun NEEDS a safety !!!

Kahr P380 Perfect

Any current review of .380's that does not include the Smith & Wesson .380EZ is silly. Try it .. you'll agree.

Apparently these writers have not tested/shot many 380's. A shallow and lackluster useless article. Unusual for this outfit.

I disagree but for the first time with evaluations from this source
The Sig is best
and no mention of top rated Springfield Armory's new contribution
LCR always a joke but not the Ruger name, tops in other departments like LCR357

Check out the new S&W shield EZ.

I carried a Walther PPKS as a backup gun and off duty gun for years. I then carried it as a CCW gun, eventually replacing it and giving it to my son, who carries it still. As a LEO I has to qualify with it just like my duty pistol, which I did at the Expert level every year, including from the 25 yard line.
The only problem I ever had was that I have very meaty hands and the slide sliced my hand open the first time I shot it. I honed the rear edges of the slide and that problem went away.
As for accuracy, reliability, and trigger pull, all were excellent. I carried a round in the chamber all the time using the DA/SA as it is designed. It should be on the list!

I own a Walther PPK/S in 380 and I do not think it would be suitable as a carry pistol. The slide is a total bear to rack. Due to that, I have had misfeeds on the first round. I think the slide spring is stiff because it is a blowback piston. A locked breech pistol with a lighter spring might be the way to go.

No one ever mentions the SIG P238, an excellent 1911 style pistol in .380.
I believe it received an A or A- in a Gun Tests review.
Though they are not inexpensive they cost less than the Kimber and make a great pocket carry pistol.

I generally carry a Glock 43 and also have an LCP for times when the 43 just won't do. However my favorite is my Glock 19 Gen 3 which I am able to carry about 10% of the time.

I have a FEG 380, and it shoots excellently,

The Sig 938 (with Viridian green laser sight) was my daily pocket CCW for over two years without any complaints whatsoever until I made the mistake of letting my adult daughter with two teenagers take it to the range . . . which was the last time it saw the inside of my pocket ...ever ... again, as it quite suddenly became "her" daily CCW . . . Her street confidence and range results both improved most rapidly (i.e. - immediately) !!!

A few, brief comments:

As has been noted, the LCP II is much improved over the original version. Kimbers are great guns, but they are simply too finicky in terms of ammunition for me. I have owned several Sig P238s, and they would probably be my first choice had I not purchased a P938 for just a little more. My reason: 9 mm ammo is too cheap to pass up and more effective than .380.

And finally, my favorite carry gun is the .22 magnum Smith & Wesson 351PD revolver. Lighter in weigh than all but maybe one of your five choices, at least as many round capacity and more than most of your five, and just a great little shooter. To my way of thinking, if you feel comfortable with a less potent round than a 9 mm or a 38 special revolver, I personally feel just as comfortable carrying a .22 magnum revolver than I would a .380 semi-auto. It's also way less expensive.

I like the CZ83. I have one in 9 Makarov and I find it rugged, reliable, and pretty darned accurate.

I have for years had the perfect pocket-carry -- Taurus PT 788 .380 with an extended mag. It offers complete concealment and easy access.

I agree with most of the selections in this article, and am vey partial to the Baby Rock, but was very surprised to not see listed, my personal choice for first place...the ageless and dependable Walther PPK. I Castries on as a backup weapon for 30+ years and have yet to find a weapon that is superior.

I have a Browning Black Label with a 4.25" barrel. Flat and light, great for summer carry. It launches a 90 gr. Underwood at 1280 fps.

Meh . . . a very lackluster article based on what?

I own the Kimber in 9mm and I really like it.. I also own the Sig 238 and have never had one, not one hiccup out of it. I LOVE that gun. It has night sights and I believe its still in production . I hope to buy the 938 once I'm convinced Sig has all the bugs out of it. It's about the same size as the P238 but in 9mm.

I usually AGREE with preferences from this site, as well as Hickok45 presentations. This one, however has me scratching my head ... perhaps the longer barrels = more tiny 380 "punch" was the factor that deviated these choices away from others that better fill the bill using this theme in the title? When shopping for gals, with them & at range, this criteria seems more foolproof when they are self protecting:
1. CT green laser (w/light optional), no other laser that stays on or is red (for night only)
2. Night sights
3. Will not fail to feed 90 Grain FTX - Hornady Critical Defense = best expansion + penetration ref. lucky gunner labs self-defense-ammo-ballistic-tests #380ACP
4. Most friendly to handle & conceal was ...... SAUER P238 Night Sights, Tan finish
5. Best fit holster or purse & automobile carry - all must cover trigger

An often overlooked .380 is the FEG Mark II, deep blue black, steel, well made 380 that is smooth, doesn't need 'dehorning', great finish all around and shoots like a dream due to the ergonomics,thumb rest on the left grip and weight. Several 380ties are not a lot of fun to shoot. a Hungarian-made FEG Mark II AP semi-automatic pistol, double-action (DA/SA) pistol is patterned after the world famous Walther PP. It features a 3.9" barrel, and fixed sights. Like the Walther, the hammer is exposed, and there is a slide-mounted safety/decocker. Bottom line you won't find a better shooter and it is affordable, I like steel guns. Imported until 1998 but available on GB or Private Sales.

I have an original, made in Germany, Walther PPK purchased in 1966. I bought the piece when I was being readied to ship out from Fort Polk, LA. The ship out never happened but I have had the pistol ever since. It has always behaved 100%, but does not like cheap-ass ammo. I usually carried Hi-Vel ammo but it does bite a bit with that load. I later obtained a PPK in .22LR. That is sweet to shoot but less powerful than some prefer.

The Ruger LCPs has a REALLY nice trigger and is so affordable now it's hard to believe. I actually now carry a Glock 43 with a CT laser. Its a 9mm and not a lot larger than these .380s.

The newer Ruger LCP II should be on this list also as well as the Beretta 380.

The LCP II is much improved over the original LCP, and is very reasonably priced and widely available.

I have had two Sig P230's and never had a problem with either.

I have to agree that my Sig 232 stn stl w/ factory nite sights probably should be counted among the best. I bought one for myself and one for my daughter some years ago when the $$ cost was reasonable;
My post ( or should I say my vent) has to do with Gun Reviews: Some years ago I purchased a Bersa Thunder based on a "Glowing Review" that I read in a magazine that I trusted. This gun had been De-Horned and since My Sig 232 was ever increasing in value I wanted something less valuable for every day carry. This Bersa could not fire two rounds without stove piping or jamming. additionally it would only chamber ball ammo, any hollow points wouldn't even load in the Mag. I sent it back for factory repair twice with no change in performance. They finally told me that I must be limp wristing the gun. Keep in mind that I have never had any problem firing the other (5) hand guns that I have chambered for .380...I now carry the Ruger LCP .380 and have for the last two years with no problems. Bottom Line "lessons learned" : Like buying shoes..."Never buy it until you try it" Thanks

At the range that a little pistol like these would be used I would think that the .380 that held fifteen or more rounds would be more important than the .380 that is accurate but only holds five rounds!

If you are left handed - substitute the Sig p238 for the Kimber Micro Carry - You can get Sigs with an ambi safety on some P238 configurations or buy the parts and do it yourself on the others. I own three and am very happy wit them.

You forgot the Sig which scores high on any list.

Whatever happened to the Browning 380 semi auto and the Beretta 380 semi auto? Both quality made firearms with a proven and lengthy track record. Both are still available in both new and used condition. They are not cheap but you get what you pay for. The Browning is an older design from the 1910 version and it came in a target version to get around the 1968 Gun Law about imported small firearms. The Beretta both in the 1934 WW2 version as well as the new hicap version make superb pistols. Look them up. Also how about the Mauser HSC 380 semi auto made by both Mauser and the Italian version? Also WW2 versions are still out there

I my not so humble opinion you missed two of the best:

The venerable Walther PPK or PPK/S the one that could easily be said is the one that started it all, that is still in production since 1929!

My personal favorite the SigP230/232. A little heavy in all stainless but there is an aluminum alloy frame model. A gorgeous rock solid performer.Every time I find one in reasonable condition I buy it. Not brought to this country since 2014 so there are occasional safe queens found.