Weighing in on Cartridges and QC

Reader Paul digs deep into what to call the 45 Colt round. And regarding Colt's quality-control issues, Reader Ken says, "Me too!' and Reader Jerry adds his two cents about problems with S&W.

0

Cartridges and Cartridge Names

To Gun Tests Staff: In this article you write, “Although it was designed for the 44 Magnum, the [Colt Anaconda’s] size also made it a natural choice for a big-bore non-magnum cartridge bearing the manufacturer’s name — the 45 Colt, also called the 45 Long Colt (LC) to eliminate confusion with the 45 ACP (Automatic Colt Pistol), which is often called 45 Colt informally.”

I find the use of the term 45 Long Colt confusing as there is no such caliber. Look at the headstamp on the cartridge case, it reads, “45 Colt.” For a gun chambered in that caliber, it is marked, “45 Colt.” I have never seen a cartridge, cartridge case, or gun marked, “45 Long Colt.”

I have a box of Jamison Brass & Ammunition 45 Colt ammunition. The box is marked: .45 Colt 200 Grain RNFP Legacy Grade Ammunition. On the cartridge cases the headstamp is 45 COLT.

If, prior to the introduction of the 45 Colt, there had been a cartridge called the 45 Short Colt, I could see a rationale for the term 45 Long Colt for a similar round with a longer cartridge case. But there is no 45 Short Colt cartridge.

However, apparently the 45 Long Colt designation is more widely used than I was aware of. I looked at the Colt Commercial Products catalog and there they list the caliber both ways. For the Anaconda revolver it’s 45 Colt and for the Single Action Army it’s 45 Long Colt. On the Colt’s Manufacturing Company website they show the Single Action Army, Caliber: 45 Colt.

I looked at some reloading manuals, and in Nosler Reloading Guide Number Four, they list the caliber as 45 Colt only. In Speer Manual Number 12 they list the caliber as 45 Colt with no reference to 45 Long Colt. In the Hornady Handbook, 9th Edition they list the caliber as 45 Colt, but include this information: “Like many of its outlaw contemporaries, the 45 Colt is also known by at least one alias, the best known being 45 Long Colt. This is the improper name for the cartridge and was never used as a legitimate descriptor for the cartridge. It was likely coined to help differentiate the 45 Colt from the younger, shorter, 45 S&W Schofield which could be used in guns chambered for 45 Colt, but not vice-versa. Like many legends from the Old West, one can only speculate where the 45 Long Colt moniker originated.”

You write about confusion between the 45 Colt and 45 ACP. Regarding the use of the term 45 ACP for the 45 Auto cartridge, the Hornady Manual says, “45 ACP is a moniker commonly used to describe the 45 Automatic, however this is the incorrect description of the cartridge, but is the correct descriptor for the gun the cartridge is fired in. (The 45 Automatic Colt Pistol.)” The Nosler Reloading Guide lists the caliber as 45 Auto (ACP). In the Speer Manual they list the caliber as 45 Auto, but write, “Also known as the 45 ACP (Automatic Colt Pistol). I agree with Hornady that 45 ACP is the incorrect description of the 45 Auto cartridge, but it’s certainly an interesting issue and many people use the term 45 ACP.

I really enjoy the magazine and your great articles. Keep up the good work. — Paul 

Hey Paul: Yes, “45 Colt” is the accurate name of the round and by far the most common usage. To us, it’s worth making sure that people who might informally call a cartridge by one name know exactly which round we’re talking about. Myself, I object to the use of the word “caliber” instead of “cartridge.” They aren’t nearly the same thing, but in terms of language usage, I’m in the minority, by far. — Todd Woodard

 

Re “Firing Line,” 

April-May 2026

I was not surprised by Tom’s problems with his new Colt Python. I have had to rebarrel five Colt ARs over the years. Mostly due to lack of accuracy, but my own Colt Match barrel was shedding the chrome lining on a tight patch. These rifles were all built in the late 1980s or early 1990s. Hopefully, Colt has fixed this problem, but it has flavored my opinion of the brand. — Ken

 

In the April-May issue, I read the comments from Tom, who has an issue with the quality control from Colt. I’m beginning to wonder if this is becoming a problem in the industry. We all know that both Colt and S&W are not the companies they were several decades ago. I recently bought an S&W Mountain Gun in 44 Magnum. I waited a long time for it to come in, and when it did, I was very disappointed. Taking it out of the box, I saw casting marks on the frame. I’ve attached a photo of the casting marks above the trigger. Also, I almost could not get the gun open. It was terribly hard to get the cylinder to release, and when it did, it was hard to swing it out. When open, it was obvious the gun was not even cleaned from test firing. The gun was sent back to the factory, and I got it back after four weeks. It looks and functions fine while dry firing, but, as of yet, I did not have a chance to shoot it. When I got it back, there was not a word from S&W. Things are not the same today. Like Tom, I want to know where is the quality control? Someone had to open and close my Mountain Gun to test-fire it, yet they put it in the box and okayed it. Where is the pride in their work? Like Tom with Colt, it will be some time before I will buy another S&W. — Jerry

 

Re “12-Gauge Shotshell-Firing Guns From Mossberg and Citadel,”

February-March 2026

I read this article in the February issue on “weapons” like Mossberg’s 12-gauge Shockwave. I scooped one up as soon as I heard about it. It was a pump gun, so I added a sling, an Op-Sol insert to feed shorter Aguila “shorty” shotgun shells, and finally, a green dot. With the Aguilas, I can get a couple of extra shells into the mag now, and the shorter shells feed every time and are very adequate for home and close-quarters (Hi, how are ya?) distances. They don’t kick too hard either. Just thought you’d like to know. — Mark